Report duplicate listings/pages (coins)

Others are fixed.

Keep: N#181789

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces362776.html

Trooper8

One that wasn't done by bad referees, so I'm posting it:

 

N#240814

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces314428.html

Still not resolved after 2 “fixes” in the last 1.5 months.

Jarcek

maneeshks

Please merge:

 

1 Yakgani - Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah , N# 210227

 

into

 

8 Gani - Qutb Ud Din Mubarak Shah, N# 155682

 

Both have a reference to GG# D271, which is a Billon coin.

The first one (1 Yakgani) shows it as a copper coin. The second one is correctly shown as a Billon coin.

Isn't just first (copper one) wrongly referenced?

The first one (1 Yakgani - Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah , N# 210227) mentions copper, 2.96g, 14mm, 2.6mm thickness. 

There are 4 copper coins listed for Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah in Gordon & Goenka (GG), none of which are listed in Numista catalogue - 

a. GG# D280 - Paika - 4.6g 

b. GG# D281 - 'Adli (half paika)  Hadrat Dar al-Khilafa - 2.2g

c, GG# D282 - 'Adli Qutbabad - 2.2g

d. GG# D283 - Visva (one-fifth paika) - 0.8g

The weights of these 4 copper coins do not march with 1 Yakgani (N# 210227)

These 4 copper coins are in square orientation (both Obv and Rev) whereas for 1 Yakgani (N# 210227) the Obv is in rhombus (with an inner square) and Rev in square orientation. 

There are no copper coins listed for Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah in Michael Mitchener - Oriental coins and their values 

In N# 155682  GG#D271 equivalent for Mitch is shown as W# 2577.

______________________________

Looking for another coin from Qutb Ud-Din (al-Din) Mubarak coin with the orientation - Obv is in rhombus (with an inner square) and Rev in square - I find GG# D276, Four Gani, 3.6 - 3.7g. While the weight is the same as D#271, Obv does not have an inner square and the lettering is different from GG# D271.

______________________________

A close look at 8 Gani - Qutb Ud Din Mubarak Shah  and  1 Yakgani - Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah   shows the two coins are same in orientation, have a central square on Obv and lettering is the same.

______________________________

In conclusion, everything I have found till now points to both these coins being the same one.

The following two coins are the same, but listed under different titles

N#281197

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces346816.html

I do not know hat happens next, but assume owners of one of these coins will be moved to the other coin, prior to deletion.

Duplicated coin:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces376717.html

N#375421

bjherbison

Keep: N#181789

 

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces362776.html

 

Done.

Keep - N#375432

Delete - https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces379191.html

Mistakenly added twice.

N#91048

N#94075

Keep: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces376717.html

Delete: N#375421

brismike

Keep - N#375432

 

Delete - https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces379191.html

 

Mistakenly added twice.

Thank you.  Done.

Trooper8

Trooper8

One that wasn't done by bad referees, so I'm posting it:

 

N#240814

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces314428.html

Still not resolved after 2 “fixes” in the last 1.5 months.

The first one has been kept, the users moved, and the better photos used.  If other changes are appropriate, please submit modification request.  Thanks for the reminder.

COINMAN1

The following two coins are the same, but listed under different titles

 

N#281197

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces346816.html

 

I do not know hat happens next, but assume owners of one of these coins will be moved to the other coin, prior to deletion.

Done.

coinmaniacbg

Duplicated coin:

 

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces376717.html

N#375421

Done.  The earlier one has been kept.

Fire Blade5

Keep: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces376717.html

 

Delete: N#375421

This was also noticed by another user and has now been done.

Trooper8

N#91048

N#94075

I think these are OK.

According to this Elsen auction description, the type was struck in Prague (Bohemia) with mint marks crown, lion or helmet facing right, and also in Luxembourg with helmet facing left.  

https://www.numisbids.com/n.php?p=lot&sid=837&lot=651

Confusing, and I am not sure the attached auction listings are all correctly assigned. 

tdziemia

Trooper8

N#91048

N#94075

I think these are OK.

According to this Elsen auction description, the type was struck in Prague (Bohemia) with mint marks crown, lion or helmet facing right, and also in Luewmbourg with helmet facing left.  

https://www.numisbids.com/n.php?p=lot&sid=837&lot=651

Confusing, and I am not sure the attached auction listings are all correctly assigned. 

The thing is that the Luxembourg coin also has the Prague mint listed and I'm pretty sure the mintmark on the pictures are both the same currently? Or are these two helmets looking in different directions?

As I said … confusing.

Delmonte #384 (Luxembourg) lists all three mint marks: lion, helmet or crown.  They do not differentiate helmet left or right.  But Delmonte was published in 1964.

The Elsen description suggests some newer findings that differentiate the helmet facing left vs. right (but I agree, I can't tell the difference).  

I'm not sure what's in the Bohemia catalog or how recent it is.

In my opinion we should have the Bohemia coin only with Prague mint and the Luxembourg coin only with Luxembourg mint for this to make sense.  I will edit a bit.

tdziemia

As I said … confusing.

 

Delmonte #384 (Luxembourg) lists all three mint marks: lion, helmet or crown.  They do not differentiate helmet left or right.  But Delmonte was published in 1964.

 

The Elsen description suggests some newer findings that differentiate the helmet facing left vs. right (but I agree, I can't tell the difference).  

I'm not sure what's in the Bohemia catalog or how recent it is.

 

In my opinion we should have the Bohemia coin only with Prague mint and the Luxembourg coin only with Luxembourg mint for this to make sense.  I will edit a bit.

 

 

 

  

I know only it was a coin meant for international trade. It was also minted during time he was absent from Bohemia and used Bohemia as financial base.

I have edited the Luxembourg listing to provide a picture with the helmet (mint mark) left which is believed to be the mark for coins struck in Luxembourg.

And removed auction listings that call the coin as Bohemia.  

Hello.

A duplicated coin:

Keep:

N#377761

Delete:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces379802.html

Best regards 

Turi

Duplicated 

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces297734.html

N#345087

Duplicated

N#345120

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces178425.html

Duplicated

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces178425.html

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces178426.html

I guess the “pattern” ones are a bit more complete, so this three

N#345087

N#345120

N#345121

Should be moved to were they belong:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/aef-1.html#r_aef774

Example:

N#1804

Solved.

Thanks,

Ali

Turi

Hello.

 

A duplicated coin:

 

Keep:

N#377761

 

Delete:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces379802.html

 

Best regards 

Turi

I removed the duplicate, but I think this was created in order to populate the new sections on Afghanistan > States (for the civic coppers), so I will also submit a Modification Request for the one that was kept.

maneeshks

Jarcek

maneeshks

Please merge:

 

1 Yakgani - Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah , N# 210227

 

into

 

8 Gani - Qutb Ud Din Mubarak Shah, N# 155682

 

Both have a reference to GG# D271, which is a Billon coin.

The first one (1 Yakgani) shows it as a copper coin. The second one is correctly shown as a Billon coin.

Isn't just first (copper one) wrongly referenced?

The first one (1 Yakgani - Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah , N# 210227) mentions copper, 2.96g, 14mm, 2.6mm thickness. 

There are 4 copper coins listed for Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah in Gordon & Goenka (GG), none of which are listed in Numista catalogue - 

a. GG# D280 - Paika - 4.6g 

b. GG# D281 - 'Adli (half paika)  Hadrat Dar al-Khilafa - 2.2g

c, GG# D282 - 'Adli Qutbabad - 2.2g

d. GG# D283 - Visva (one-fifth paika) - 0.8g

The weights of these 4 copper coins do not march with 1 Yakgani (N# 210227)

These 4 copper coins are in square orientation (both Obv and Rev) whereas for 1 Yakgani (N# 210227) the Obv is in rhombus (with an inner square) and Rev in square orientation. 

 

There are no copper coins listed for Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah in Michael Mitchener - Oriental coins and their values 

In N# 155682  GG#D271 equivalent for Mitch is shown as W# 2577.

 

______________________________

 

Looking for another coin from Qutb Ud-Din (al-Din) Mubarak coin with the orientation - Obv is in rhombus (with an inner square) and Rev in square - I find GG# D276, Four Gani, 3.6 - 3.7g. While the weight is the same as D#271, Obv does not have an inner square and the lettering is different from GG# D271.

______________________________

 

A close look at 8 Gani - Qutb Ud Din Mubarak Shah  and  1 Yakgani - Qutb Ud-Din Mubarak Shah   shows the two coins are same in orientation, have a central square on Obv and lettering is the same.

______________________________

 

In conclusion, everything I have found till now points to both these coins being the same one.

Hello! Please look into this, it seems to have been overlooked.

All should be fixed now.

Not sure what to do with the Connecticut coppers.? This page has all of them, as they are one type of coin, but with different varieties.

This is to keep:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces352477.html

However, in the coin catalog there are lots of pages for individual Connecticut coppers.

So these are to be deleted:

N#66817

N#66818

N#66821

N#66823

N#66824

N#66825

N#66820

N#66827

N#66828

N#66831

N#66830

N#66832

N#66834

N#66836

N#66837

N#66838

N#66839

N#66840

N#66841

N#92614

N#92615

Other way around, these are different types as far as I can see.

Hi

Can we merge these two duplicates.

Keep: N#59960
Delete: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces99234.html

The first lists all the officinas, while the second only has the second officina.

There are 54 people who claim to have the second coin, but I think we should merge them as ‘undetermined’ rather than ‘second officina’ since the mintmark listed for the second coin (SMANT) doesn't exist for this issue and would never mean second officina anyway. (SMANT seems to be an error copied from Wildwinds several times).

Thank you

Merged!

Please delete the coin

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces113649.html

moving the owners to the “undetermined” line of the correct one

N#364608

It looks like the 1963 2.5 Rupiah Irian Jaya pattern is listed twice, though I'm not 100% sure. I found the double listing when looking for all Irian Jaya coins, when accidently looking for ALL coins.
One under Rupiah (1950-1965): N#168929

One under Rupiah (1962-1971): N#352478

The first listing has good information of sizes that are missing on the second one, also the picture on the first listing is better, however for the second listing the Rupiah years seem to make more sense as other coins are listed under those years as well.

The first misses coin allignment though, while the second listing misses an edge desription. The second has rarity 100.
It seems a merge should be made keeping all the information available, as well as the best pictures and then place the merge under 1962-1971.

The first is listed as KM#PN3, the second as KM#PN2, but I can't find any differences between the images.

I put them together all in one image, left is the second listing (format increased 200%), the right coin is the first listing (format decreased to 40%):

I think the difference is the edge lettering. Album mentions it for PN3: https://www.coinarchives.com/w/lotviewer.php?LotID=6492336&AucID=7532&Lot=1065&Val=0b6d7e969f52ca4420b8a84ba416694f

But not PN2: https://www.sarc.auction/IRIAN-BARAT-AL-2-1-2-rupiah-1963_i20307648

So the two can remain, but PN2 needs an edge description of ‘no lettering’.

 

John Conduitt

I think the difference is the edge lettering. Album mentions it for PN3: https://www.coinarchives.com/w/lotviewer.php?LotID=6492336&AucID=7532&Lot=1065&Val=0b6d7e969f52ca4420b8a84ba416694f

But not PN2: https://www.sarc.auction/IRIAN-BARAT-AL-2-1-2-rupiah-1963_i20307648

So the two can remain, but PN2 needs an edge description of ‘no lettering’.

 

The ‘no lettering’ makes sense, unfortunately there is no ‘no lettering’ mentioned in that PN2 link… (At least, I don't see it)
For that reason I cannot send a modification request, more evidence is needed.

Hello. Referring to this thread:  https://en.numista.com/forum/topic121009.html

Please delete
N#152252 
N#108293 

N#108266 

and keep

N#49461 

N#49445 

N#49462 

thank you in advance

cobrapel

Please delete the coin

 

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces113649.html

 

moving the owners to the “undetermined” line of the correct one

 

N#364608

Done.

Dear All,

Can we please mere the below two coins:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces226222.html

N#173174

Thanks,

Ali

All done now.

Hello, may I ask to delete:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces69918.html 

and keep:

N#300130

thank you in advance

Your first link gives a log list of coins.

It looks like this is the coin to remove?  https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces69918.html

Oh, sorry. Yes, https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces69918.html is the one I would like to remove

Done.

Alderney 2010 Silver Proof Gold plated:

Please delate: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces351827.html

And keep the one: N#367537

Done, thanks!

Please can we merge:
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces37009.html (delete)
and
N#140370

Where the people from the first have the 3rd officina (Γ).

Thank you

Fixed.

Same coin on not?

N#380019

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces382480.html

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces379886.html

What I see now is that, in mine mind, these coins are the same :

N#301685. —-  should be deleted
N#19871  —  keep!

by the way : is it possible to add a section in Spain with Catalunya (region around Barcelona), where these coins can be registered in ( now it is UNKWON country)??

Hello!

A Dublicate that needs to be deleted:

Please keep this coin: N#251397

But delete this one: N#251396

It hopefully shouldnt be an issue since nobody entered the second coin in the collection so far.

Regards Erdnussbier

Erdnussbier

Hello!

 

A Dublicate that needs to be deleted:

 

Please keep this coin: N#251397

But delete this one: N#251396

 

It hopefully shouldnt be an issue since nobody entered the second coin in the collection so far.

 

Regards Erdnussbier

 

It is not the same coin page, as can be seen on the different reference numbers listed. BUT the pictures on the second page are indeed wrong. I made a change request with correct pictures.

Hello Trooper!

Thank you very much for the clarification.

This settles the matter.

Regards,

Erdnussbier

All fixed now. Thank you!

Jarcek

All fixed now. Thank you!

These too??

What I see now is that, in mine mind, these coins are the same :

N#301685. —-  should be deleted
N#19871  —  keep!

by the way : is it possible to add a section in Spain with Catalunya (region around Barcelona), where these coins can be registered in ( now it is UNKWON country)??

Jarcek

All fixed now. Thank you!

These too??

What I see now is that, in mine mind, these coins are the same :

N#301685. —-  should be deleted
N#19871  —  keep!

by the way : is it possible to add a section in Spain with Catalunya (region around Barcelona), where these coins can be registered in ( now it is UNKWON country)??

Yes, these were merged too. I will check for exonumia issuer.

Apologies -  Here is another duplicate.. 🙄

Keep N#379195

Delete https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces374087.html

27 Members to be moved to the BU in Coincard mintage line please.

Regards - Mike

Duplicate found here … Thanks to Trooper8

Keep this coin … N#167037

Remove 2 mintage lines on this coin … N#66615

The ones relating to Coloured BU Mintage 24,430 & Proof Coloured 3,637

Move the members (5 on BU & 1 on proof)  that have coins on  those mintage lines coins to the respective mintage  lines on the page we are keeping.

Thanks - Mike

The last two requests have been done.

These 2 seem like the same coin to me, they have the same RIC number

N#50388  

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces289179.html

N#97647

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces366400.html

Trooper8

N#97647

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces366400.html

Done, thanks.

One of the new IOM coins was issued in two sets and it was added twice but this is exactly the same coin.

Keep: N#384311

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces374838.html

I just copied info from first one entry to the one that should remain to have all info together, also I added the linę for circulated version (needed to be verified first).

Please move all users from removed entry to the second one. The page to be removed is older and is with more users but has much less info.

For this coin  >>> N#80295

Please Delete both of the the mintage lines referencing BU Coloured (23,661 & 10,000 mintage )

Move the 11 members who have the coin on those lines to be deleted 

to this coin >>> N#90478

Place them on the 23,661 mintage line please.

Thanks Mike

It seems that I added one coin twice when I recently added multiple coins from IOM& Gibraltar, just noticed it when all request approved:

Keep: N#387811

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces387542.html

MMowiec

It seems that I added one coin twice when I recently added multiple coins from IOM& Gibraltar, just noticed it when all request approved:

Keep: N#387811

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces387542.html

 

Done

Another one doubled page:

Keep: N#381298

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces375809.html

Looks that some users needs to be moved too as both coins are already added to collections.

MMowiec

Another one doubled page:

Keep: N#381298

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces375809.html

 

Looks that some users needs to be moved too as both coins are already added to collections.

Done, as well as one above with steam train

Done thank you

apuking

A Duplicate here

 

Please keep

N#281251

 

please delete and move owner to the other sheet

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces281473.html

 

Thank you,

 

Paul

Done, same user entered both coins

My post from 25th November above still pending.

Mike

Last year line of this page (F#80.12) needs to be deleted N#80964

Move owners to N#301221

Delete all year-lines except one: N#198399

The year-lines are all listed separately here now: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/index.php?e=canada_section&r=zodiac&ct=coin&im1=&im2=&tb=y&tc=y&tn=y&tp=y&tt=y&cat=y&ru=&ca=3&no=&v=3&i=&b=&d=&u=&a=&dg=2017&m=&f=&t=&w=&mt=&g=&se=&c=&wi=&sw=&ie=

Mods told me to report this duplicate listing here 

Keep:

N#60068

Delete:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces77563.html

For this coin >>> N#301977

Delete the 1998 Mintage line and move the members who have it to the 1998 Mintage line on 

This coin >>> N#389533

This coin has the same reverse but was issued with different obverse designs split over 1998 & 1999

Thanks Mike

Merge:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces247339.html

N#244033

This looks wrong at first glance, but I strongly believe RIC f***ed up big time and meant that second coin instead. The Roman Empire referee seemed to agree in private messages. And since I remember the Roman Provinces referee once saying that all coins with a RIC number should go into Roman Empire (and strikes in other metals that were forgotten by RIC but not by RPC, into provinces 🤡), I suggest to put the merged entry into the Roman Empire.

If there are further questions about this, please feel free to contact me directly.

to keep: N#355079

to delete: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces389778.html (added the last without proper checking, sorry)

Grinya

to keep: N#355079

to delete: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces389778.html (added the last without proper checking, sorry)

 

 

Please fix the reference in the coin to keep

and put years within ruler reign as is in second coin, after that I'll delete duplicated page

done. Thanks for noticing

Grinya

to keep: N#355079

to delete: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces389778.html (added the last without proper checking, sorry)

 

 

Done

gyoschak

Last year line of this page (F#80.12) needs to be deleted N#80964

Move owners to N#301221

 

Can we do this one?

gyoschak

gyoschak

Last year line of this page (F#80.12) needs to be deleted N#80964

Move owners to N#301221

 

Can we do this one?

Done

A duplicate here

please keep

N#54059

please delete

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/exonumia390183.html
 

thank you

N#352161

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces368142.html

lateko

N#352161

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces368142.html

 

Fixed

apuking

A duplicate here

 

please keep

N#54059

 

please delete

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/exonumia390183.html
 

thank you

Please do not forget this one here.

Second is also wrong as Conder Tokens are listed in Numista in the coins section.

apuking

apuking

A duplicate here

 

please keep

N#54059

 

please delete

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/exonumia390183.html
 

thank you

Please do not forget this one here.

Second is also wrong as Conder Tokens are listed in Numista in the coins section.

sorry I do not have rights to delete in exonumia section, so we need @Jarcek or @Compendium here

Done, thank you!

brismike

For this coin  >>> N#80295

 

Please Delete both of the the mintage lines referencing BU Coloured (23,661 & 10,000 mintage )

 

Move the 11 members who have the coin on those lines to be deleted 

to this coin >>> N#90478

 

Place them on the 23,661 mintage line please.

 

Thanks Mike

Done

I think it's a terrible idea that admins just cherry pick (forced or not) the requests in here they process. Because it's not a ticket system, some just get forgotten. Or do you know exactly which requests are still open in here?

I know at least 2.

TheDreadedAce

Mods told me to report this duplicate listing here 

 

Keep:

N#60068

 

Delete:

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces77563.html

Done.

Trooper8

Delete all year-lines except one: N#198399

 

The year-lines are all listed separately here now: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/index.php?e=canada_section&r=zodiac&ct=coin&im1=&im2=&tb=y&tc=y&tn=y&tp=y&tt=y&cat=y&ru=&ca=3&no=&v=3&i=&b=&d=&u=&a=&dg=2017&m=&f=&t=&w=&mt=&g=&se=&c=&wi=&sw=&ie=

This one is started and will be completed a bit later.  It takes some time (I needed to get a lesson in the zodiac signs first, since the symbols are nowhere linked to the names in the listing).

Eventually I will ask for your your list by PM.  

Edit:  Done.

Please delete duplicate

N#391592

Keep

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces364604.html

brismike

For this coin >>> N#301977

Delete the 1998 Mintage line and move the members who have it to the 1998 Mintage line on 

 

This coin >>> N#389533

 

This coin has the same reverse but was issued with different obverse designs split over 1998 & 1999

 

Thanks Mike

Done.

stefandobyy

These 2 seem like the same coin to me, they have the same RIC number

 

N#50388  

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces289179.html

 

Done.

cobrapel

Please delete duplicate

 

N#391592

 

Keep

 

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces364604.html

The auction sale needs to be removed before I can delete the listing, so you will see this as a modification request.

Done. Thanks!

Done. Thanks!

Both above from @al-Bakuvi are fixed.

Please remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces376071.html

please keep: N#383604

please move users from the one that is to be removed to the one that will be continued.

MMowiec

Please remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces376071.html

please keep: N#383604

please move users from the one that is to be removed to the one that will be continued.

Done

Another one batch of duplicated coins, Alice in wonderland 2021 set of 50p:

Keep: N#323261

Remove: 

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces386257.html

And (2 same pages added even it was already in catalogue)

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces386253.html

Keep: N#342617 

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces386209.html

Keep: N#331158

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces386250.html

Keep: N#342628

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces386260.html

Keep: N#342626

Remove: https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces386208.html