Thailand, 20 Baht 2009, wrong KM in Numista? [Risolto]

Hi, for this Thailand coin:

N#16600

Numista has the Y#506, but at Krause (and Numismaster) there are two Y's assigned to this coin: Y#506 and Y#514:

Y#506, Wrong date 2553 (2010), Subject "Princess Bejaratana, 84th Birthday", right picture.

Y#514, Right date 2552 (2009), Subject "Princess Bejaratana, 84th Birthday", NO picture.

The coin does not exist with the year 2553 (2010), so to enter a single reference, I think it would be better to be Y#514.

The same thing happens in the 800 Baht commemorative coin of the same motif, and in this case Numista refers to both: Y#507 and Y#515.

N#199697

To follow the same criteria as in the 800 Baht coin, I have made a modification request to include both references in the 20 Baht coin (including an explanation in comments), but it has been rejected by the Thai referee.

What do you think should be done? What references should be written, both, only one, which one?

Is Yeoman assigning new numbers, or has that been delegated to whoever assigns KM numbers?

In my opinion the best option (until one set of Y numbers are unassigned) is to put the correct date Y numbers in the references section and mention the other Y number only in the comment text.

I totally agree with you, the reference number that should be used in this case is Y#514 and in the comments field indicate that the other one with the wrong date exists.

If Krause (or Yeoman) assgined two numbers to one coin, we should at least mention it on the page, as users might search by both.

Hi Jarcek, my modification request included the two references in the specific field and, in the comments field, the following, both for the 20 Baht coin and for the 800 Baht coin (with its two Y numbers):

"On the 20 Baht coin dedicated to commemorating the 84th Anniversary of HRH Princess Bejaratana, two different Krause catalog numbers are associated:
Y#506, Wrong date 2553 (2010), Subject "Princess Bejaratana, 84th Birthday", right picture.
Y#514, Right date 2552 (2009), Subject "Princess Bejaratana, 84th Birthday", NO picture."

Both modification request were rejected by Thai referee, with comments “its an error in krause. its not in any thai book” Maybe he don't understand the modification requests.

oynbcn

Hi Jarcek, my modification request included the two references in the specific field and, in the comments field, the following, both for the 20 Baht coin and for the 800 Baht coin (with its two Y numbers):

 

"On the 20 Baht coin dedicated to commemorating the 84th Anniversary of HRH Princess Bejaratana, two different Krause catalog numbers are associated:
Y#506, Wrong date 2553 (2010), Subject "Princess Bejaratana, 84th Birthday", right picture.
Y#514, Right date 2552 (2009), Subject "Princess Bejaratana, 84th Birthday", NO picture."

 

Both modification request were rejected by Thai referee, with comments “its an error in krause. its not in any thai book” Maybe he don't understand the modification requests.

Please appeal the decision, so work is not lost.

Done for the two coins. Thanks!!!