CR approved but not visible on brazilian note

Hello,

I made a CR to put engraver, designer names and remove an english comment from the lettering section, as you can see it was approved:

But when I double check my edits the comments is still there:

So I guess a bug should have occur during the validation process, please can you checked what happened?

It seems Vladthiengo changed the entry just after validating your change.

But why a referee would accept a CR to then remove it to integrate a comment in lettering??????????

Hello!

I was going to accept the changes, except for the "lettering note", but I ended up accepting all the changes and returning to what was previously.

However, there is an understanding that comments should be avoided in the field of lettering. Therefore, I will be returning to the suggestion made by Indomini16 on October 2nd. =)

Thanks for reporting here!

Best Regards,
Vladimir.

Perfect, thanks!

vladthiengo

However, there is an understanding that comments should be avoided in the field of lettering. 

It's not an understanding… and it should not be avoid, it's strictly prohibated! I'm very surprised to see that not all referees are aware of that very basic rule.

It surprise me how you allways seem to be surprised by the referees, you should not by now don't you think ? 😲 

Why allways complain in the forums ? Follow the appeal process, as asked by Compendium repeatidly in different threads, and wait like everyone else do. If the Appeal process is not up to your expectations, maybe you should write private messages to the Numista team members (Xavier, Jarcek and Compendium) as asked by Compendium also. Why don't you follow the directions from Compendium when he ask you to do something… and stop the public bashing of referees and complain about the Appeal process. You are complaining about referees not following the guidelines but you are also not following direct instructions. 

Again, why don't you become a referee yourself ? By now, you surely have acquired the knowledge and you look to have all the time needed on your hands.

André,

Québécois

Why allways complain in the forums ?

I will surprise you, but I don’t always do, often I just accept referee decision.

In this particular case I didn’t think it was corrected afterward so no reason to appeal as I thought it was a bug, so no complain but just a bug report. Is that more clear for you?

Indomini16

 

It's not an understanding… and it should not be avoid, it's strictly prohibated! I'm very surprised to see that not all referees are aware of that very basic rule.

This comment is not a bug report, it's just being rude to referees in general…as usual and very frequently. 
[Rest of the message deleted by moderators]

Québécois

This comment is not a bug report, it's just being rude to referees in general…

You are not understanding me well, this comment is not against referees but how they are train to do their job.

I am not rude to referee here but worry about how they are supporte.

I made this thread about it a while ago

For the rest, I’m surprised to see how much you care for me, that’s nice of you :)

Same old story…public complaints about one or more referees or admins not doing enough according to your standards…like we are all stupid and we can't understand what is a language dependant field.

Again, you were ask to make CR and appeal if necessary but you continue to post your cases in the forum.

You're just a bully and I don't care what contributions you make here, if you don't change your manners, you should not get and don't deserve our cooperation.

Indomini16

You are not understanding me well, this comment is not against referees but how they are train to do their job.

I am not rude to referee here but worry about how they are supporte.

I feel I must make a comment here. I have a job, it is not being a referee for Numista. Being a referee for Numista is an extension of a hobby I enjoy doing. There was no training involved. With the help of all of the Numista team I continue to learn. If being a volunteer referee stops providing continued enjoyment to the hobby I enjoy then I will reconsider my involvement as a volunteer referee. For the most part I find your involvement helpful. If you don't get your way, I find it less helpful.

Just a reminder who and what a referee's JOB is.

Catalog referees

Referees are volunteers who commit their time and knowledge to coordinate the improvements to the catalog for specific issuers or groups of issuers. They review the changes in the catalog for the issuers in their scope and they improve the catalog by adding missing information and enforcing consistency to the catalog guidelines.

Totally agree with Québécois and JLHare. Being a referee at Numista is something that many of us do for the simple pleasure of collaborating (the best we know and can) and it is very easy to look for errors in the work done by others and then post them in the Forum. 

With certain attitudes it is easier for some regular collaborators to become demotivated. I don't think it is the ideal way to improve the website.

This is my humble and personal opinion, without trying to bother anyone or detract from the work done by each and every one of us.

Hello,
I believe the issue was answered in the first few replies, clarifying this is not a bug.

If being a volunteer referee stops providing continued enjoyment to the hobby I enjoy then I will reconsider my involvement as a volunteer referee.

This is so true…I'm reconsidering as of now… I think I will enjoy more collaborating to this site as a user.

When you don't appreciate at it's value the work of a volunteer be sure you are willing and able to replace him. 😉