It should not be possible to add an item which does not exist to own collection

Pubblicazioni di 5 • visto 82 volte

Questo messaggio ha lo scopo di: suggerisci un'idea per migliorare Numista

Stato Aperto
Voti positivi: 1
Voti negativi: 0

To prevent errors, I suggest that it should not be possible for anyone to add an item which does not exist to their numista collection.

 

For example, having a listing for a fully redeemed banknote, that is no examples left outstanding, with members indicating that the note is in their collection, is disinformation which gives the impression that examples of the banknote do exist. 

 

Here is one such listing. This note: Ulster Bank £100, 6.5.29
N#231286
is a fully redeemed series. 


There are no examples extant according to the records of the Central Bank of Ireland. Yet, according to the numista listing someone claims to have one! It is probably an error. It would be a good thing to prevent such errors from occurring in the catalogue.

 

Thoughts, suggestions, opinions please people!

 

Specimens exist of the general Type with Bank of Ireland on them, but not of the Ulster Bank, so this error cannot be a specimen.

Basically that's a very sound suggestion, but of course you can easily delete the item in your collection once you have falsely entered it in the Numista database! 😖

Globetrotter
Coin varieties in French:
https://monnaiesetvarietes.numista.com

Why add unattainable items into the database in the first place then?

Idolenz

Why add unattainable items into the database in the first place then?

I didn't add them - it is a good question. I guess they are part of the historical record, and are included in the various catalogues which cover the issues.

Sjoelund

…but of course you can easily delete the item in your collection once you have falsely entered it in the Numista database! 😖

Probably, but I do wonder at the motive of the member who added them, an ego boost perhaps? The need to pretend to own half a dozen banknotes which if the y did exist would be worth $50K each. Rather silly, I think, but all need hobbies, I suppose.

» Politica del Forum

Il fuso orario utilizzato è UTC+2:00.
L'ora attuale è 06:33.