Modification requests

this MR seems to be messed up, it shows images for obverse and reverse, from totally different coins, which I definitely didn't submit
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/contributions/voir_demande.php?id=510391
I think I asked for changing obverse and reverse pictures, which are now correct, but the descriptions are still for the wrong sides (I'm making a new request)

and just an idea: could you add a column for "previous value" so we can compare in detail what we proposed to change?

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/contributions/voir_demande_date.php?id=514343
the link to the coin page is messed up, I think this happens with all year change MRs

there's something wrong with this coin sheet
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces17921.html
when I want to remove the "commemorating issue" by setting it to no or unknown, I get a result "the coin sheet has been changed, thank you for editing", but it is not changed.
(I think pattern coins are not commemorative issues, as they are not issues at all)

Hello Androl,

I've corrected the page which displays the modification request to the user (the admin page was correct and your request was correctly taken into account).

Concerning your suggestion, it's unfortunately not possible for members to see the previous values of a coin sheet.

Lastly, the coin sheet #17921 is marked as "Non circulating commemorative issue". You have to change "Circulating issue" into "Unknown" and then "Commemorative issue" into "No" or "Unknown".
Btw, I changed the confirmation message, so it says that nothing changed when the sheet isn't actually modified.

Cita: XavierLastly, the coin sheet #17921 is marked as "Non circulating commemorative issue". You have to change "Circulating issue" into "Unknown" and then "Commemorative issue" into "No" or "Unknown".
Btw, I changed the confirmation message, so it says that nothing changed when the sheet isn't actually modified.

when I change "Circulating issue" into "Unknown" first, the moderator won't know what I want to do. Why can't changing "Commemorative issue" into "No" or "Unknown" just make a request that I want to remove both "Circulating issue" and "Commemorative issue" at once?

Hello,
You can make just one request to change it. Check "Circulating issue" as "Unknown", check "Commemorative issue" as "No" or "Unknown", and click the button "Modify data". This will remove the mention "Uncirculated commemorative issue" at once.

Cita: XavierYou can make just one request to change it. Check "Circulating issue" as "Unknown", check "Commemorative issue" as "No" or "Unknown", and click the button "Modify data". This will remove the mention "Uncirculated commemorative issue" at once.

no, it does not
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/contributions/voir_demande.php?id=527062
Field Given value
Circulating issue : Unknown

I tried with a not locked coin:

Circulating issue :  Yes or Unknown
->
changing Commemorative issue to no or unknown will work
deleting Commemorated event will set Commemorative issue to Unknown

Circulating issue :  No
->
changing Commemorative issue to no or unknown will delete the Commemorated event but will not change Commemorative issue

when I change Circulating issue to yes or unknown at a locked coin and change Commemorative issue to (no or) unknown at the same time, only the Circulating issue change will be put into the request, and the Commemorative issue will not be changed and not be put into the request, because the Circulating issue is still at No and has not yet been changed

edit: when I change Commemorative issue to No at a locked coin, it works like you say, both entries are put into the request
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/contributions/voir_demande.php?id=528495 here I changed Commemorative issue to Unknown
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/contributions/voir_demande.php?id=528496 here I changed Commemorative issue to No

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces7683.html
this coin is set to
Demonetized coin = Yes
Demonetization date [] - [] - 1963

when I edit the coin and don't touch the Demonetized coin entries, they are still put into the requests
Demonetized coin Yes
Demonetization date: 1963-00-00


edit:
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces16106.html
here the same occurs with the obverse description
is it because of the line break? (there's a linke break after Defiant Condor which I removed now)

Cita: androlwhen I change Circulating issue to yes or unknown at a locked coin and change Commemorative issue to (no or) unknown at the same time, only the Circulating issue change will be put into the request, and the Commemorative issue will not be changed and not be put into the request, because the Circulating issue is still at No and has not yet been changed

edit: when I change Commemorative issue to No at a locked coin, it works like you say, both entries are put into the request
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/contributions/voir_demande.php?id=528495 here I changed Commemorative issue to Unknown
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/contributions/voir_demande.php?id=528496 here I changed Commemorative issue to No

with some coins it works, with others it does not

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces10383.html
when I change circulating to unknown and commemorative to no, only the circulating=unknown is put into the request and the moderator is confused and refuses

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces13721.html
on this coin something similar happens, I cannot change it to commemorative issue. When I enter comm. issue = yes and circulating = no, only the circulating = no will be put into the request, while comm. issue = yes is done without request, with no effect, as comm. issue = yes and circulating = unknown is always reset to comm. issue = unknown.

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces6668.html
on this coin, I set comm. issue to yes, and in the request it says set comm. issue to unknown.

https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces22131.html

there's a problem with the "1,000" in the weight field. It is displayed as "1,000", but when I click save, this is seen as a non-numeric value. When this happens, I get a red message, and the "demonetized coin" field is magically set to "yes" although it was "no" before

Poland YA47 Year 1973 MW (Mennica Warszawska - Warsaw Mint)
comment Kremnica Mint should be deleted
unfortunetly my change request was rejected  
kuba997