Inaccurate description of 10 centimes France

Pubblicazioni di 3
In the article
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces321.html
the section of years distribution marks from time to time the size of holes.

To do that statement there should be known that this size during the coinage does not change.

So the question: does it?


Suppose now, that it was proved that it does not change. [Further is just an imagination, and have no meaning without the solving the main question]
Then the size of the hole may have meaning and should be given in proper way, that is in this case each year must have the description of the size. For example in the comment there may be written that usually the size is ...mm
and then the peculiarities may be described in the years distribution.[end of imagination]

My verification for some of them
4.8 mm 1935
5.0 mm 1917, 1922, 1929, 1931-1933
5.5 mm 1919-1921, 1923, 1924, 1928

failed in obvious way.

Does it mean, that the size of the hole should be deleted from the description?
Alexander from Cyprus
eucoins.byethost9.com
My suggestions https://t.me/enjoyyourcollection
It seems only the French side got updated for that coin. Feel free to remove them and to mention there are numerous hole varieties (size, position or missing) in the comments section.
Administrateur du catalogue, référent de nombreuses nations antiques et de la Lorraine.
Catalogue administrator, numerous Antique nations and Lorraine referee.
Hi,

the holes are in my opinion NOT worth measuring, although I do it systematically, since they are with extremely different diameters(after the /), much more than coin's diameter (before the /). Here are the holed 5 centimes from my collection, since I haven't measured all my 10 centimes yet:


Year Diam /Hole Thick
1917 19,08/4,35 1,45
1918 19,14/4,75 1,41
1919 19,00/4,84 1,48
1920 19,25/5,49 1,51
1920 17,21/3,75 1,27
1921 17,23/3,74 1,34
1922 17,18/3,83 1,28
1922 17,19/4,04 1,31
1923 17,11/3,90 1,26
1923 17,10/4,02 1,35
1924 16,99/3,65 1,40
1924 17,07/4,22 1,26
1925 17,02/3,94 1,38
1926 17,03/4,27 1,27
1927 17,14/4,07 1,45
1930 17,10/3,74 1,36
1931 17,01/3,73 1,33
1932 17,01/3,85 1,32
1933 17,04/4,30 1,28
1934 16,97/4,40 1,24
1935 17,00/3,47 1,36
1936 16,99/3,95 1,31
1937 16,98/4,09 1,25
1938 16,97/4,25 1,34
1938 16,96/3,95 1,10
1939 17,05/3,75 1,18
1939 16,98/3,90 1,11

Ole
Globetrotter
Coin varieties in French:
https://monnaiesetvarietes.numista.com

» Politica del Forum

Il fuso orario utilizzato è UTC+2:00.
L'ora attuale è 18:43.