Catalog of garbage. [Risolto]

It seems that Numista describes garbages.

The article https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces5476.html
represents a common garbage: die rotation.

1409 (1989) Rotation Error:

© Amer AlZarouni




1409 (1989) ١٤٠٩ - ١٩٨٩ Rotation Error

It is common in every coinage and never cataloged by coin catalogs. If a single description of such garbage appeared in any part of the catalog you obliged to publish:

https://www.delcampe.net/en_GB/collectables/coins-banknotes/coins-euro/errors-and-oddities/free-rotation-greece-1-euro-2002-uncommon-low-start-no-reserve-333992861.html

https://www.delcampe.net/en_GB/collectables/coins-banknotes/coins/russia/large-rotation-ussr-ex-russia-3-kopecks-1931-very-rare-low-start-no-reserve-287860420.html

and so on and so on. Soon all articles will consist of these different angle rotations. The rotations are well known. If someone wish to describe them, the Numisita catalog proposed:

For specialized variants not listed in main catalogs and strike errors, you may add personal comments.

If someone wish to enjoy such garbage by angles and other die clash, die chips and so on, there is enough space at Forum for such topics.


As the result, the article should be changed:

instead of

Lettering: ١٤٠٢-١٩٨٢
Translation: 1982-1402

Comments
[...]
1409 (1989) Rotation Error:

© Amer AlZarouni


Mintage
1409 (1989) ١٤٠٩ - ١٩٨٩
1409 (1989) ١٤٠٩ - ١٩٨٩ Proof Sets (KM#MS1)
1409 (1989) ١٤٠٩ - ١٩٨٩ Rotation Error

there should be

Lettering: ١٤٠٢-١٩٨٢
Translation: 1402 - 1982

Comments
[...]

Mintage
1409 (1989) ١٤٠٩ - ١٩٨٩
1409 (1989) ١٤٠٩ - ١٩٨٩ Proof Sets (KM#MS1)

I would certainly not call it garbage. While you may not like that kind of error, there are some people who love them. So please, try to use nicer words in the future.

With that being said, you are correct about not listing errors like that in the year-lines; they should indeed be kept to the personal comments. No one even claims to own that year, actually. So... it is gone now.

Oh, how disappointing, there was me thinking there would be a catalogue listing different types and varieties of waste recycling!

Cita: "radrick007"​Oh, how disappointing, there was me thinking there would be a catalogue listing different types and varieties of waste recycling!

​There is still the token section with literal metal scrap so don't give up. There is also a bottle cap somewhere in the coin
​​​​​​catalog.

Hi, are you referring to this one
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces131407.html

regards

It seems that there the status 'done' was given here by mistake.

The rotation in question is still described in the article clearly.

In which way is it possible to withdraw it?

The article should be changed:

instead of
Lettering: ١٤٠٢-١٩٨٢
Translation: 1982-1402

Comments
[...]
1409 (1989) Rotation Error:
[photos https://en.numista.com/catalogue/images/5c176b87cef36.jpg and https://en.numista.com/catalogue/images/5c176b9a26fc6.jpg]
© Amer AlZarouni

there should be

Lettering: ١٤٠٢-١٩٨٢
Translation: 1402 - 1982

Comments
[...]
[from 1409 till AlZarouni should be deleted]

Or it is must to create a new topic to complete the correction?

While translation is fine, rotation error is really redundant, as it can happen with any coin.

Cita: "cyprusalexander"​It seems that there the status 'done' was given here by mistake.
​
​The rotation in question is still described in the article clearly.
​
​In which way is it possible to withdraw it?
​
​The article should be changed:
​
​instead of
​Lettering: ١٤٠٢-١٩٨٢
​Translation: 1982-1402
​
​Comments
​[...]
​1409 (1989) Rotation Error:
​[photos https://en.numista.com/catalogue/images/5c176b87cef36.jpg and https://en.numista.com/catalogue/images/5c176b9a26fc6.jpg]
​© Amer AlZarouni
​
​there should be
​
​Lettering: ١٤٠٢-١٩٨٢
​Translation: 1402 - 1982
​
​Comments
​[...]
​[from 1409 till AlZarouni should be deleted]
​
​Or it is must to create a new topic to complete the correction?
​
​

​It's in the comments section, so of course it's OK!

When will you ever learn to be polite and positive, or don't you know the concepts?